The Skill Mill
Bright Mind Press / Bright Mind Press / 2024-01-17

Learn how to evaluate purchases based on what matters to you rather than willpower or shame. The value-based spending framework helps ADHD adults make impulse purchases intentional

Value-Based Spending for ADHD Adults: Making Money Decisions That Actually Feel Right

You buy something impulsively, feel great for five minutes, then regret it for days. You know you shouldn't have spent the money, but in the moment, it felt necessary. You end the month confused about where your money went and feeling like you failed at self-control again.

This cycle happens because traditional approaches to impulse spending rely on restriction and willpower. Don't buy things. Say no to yourself. Control your impulses. But willpower is a limited resource, especially for ADHD brains. You can't win a battle against your brain's dopamine system by simply trying harder.

Value-based spending is different. Instead of fighting impulse, you align your spending with what actually matters to you. Some purchases will still be impulsive. Some will still be frivolous. But instead of viewing all impulse spending as failure, you'll develop a framework for distinguishing between spending that violates your values and spending that honors them. The shame drops. Your financial confidence rises. Money stops feeling like a moral battleground.

What Values-Based Spending Actually Means

Value-based spending asks you to answer one question before you buy: "Is this aligned with what I care about?"

It's not asking whether you can afford it or whether a financial advisor would approve. It's asking whether this purchase reflects your actual priorities and values. For some people, that means spending $200 on concert tickets because live music brings joy and connection. For others, it means not spending that $200 because it conflicts with their priority of financial security. Both decisions can be value-aligned.

The ADHD brain struggles with abstract values. You can't see "financial security" or "health" the way you can see a product in an online store. Value-based spending makes values concrete by asking you to translate them into time and trade-offs.

If a purchase costs $100 and you earn $25 per hour, that purchase costs four hours of your life. It costs your time, your energy, your finite number of working hours. Suddenly, the purchase is less abstract. You're trading four hours of your labor for this item. Is it worth four hours of your life?

For some purchases, yes. A good mattress might cost 40 hours of work, but if it improves your sleep and therefore your entire quality of life, those 40 hours are well spent. A $150 impulse purchase on a gadget you'll use for a week? That might not feel worth 6 hours of your life once you think about it in those terms.

The "Hours of Your Life" Calculation

This is the most practical tool in the value-based spending framework. Instead of thinking about purchases in dollars, you think about them in hours.

Calculate your hourly rate. Take your annual income and divide by 2,000 (roughly the number of working hours per year). If you earn $40,000 per year, your hourly rate is $20. This includes taxes, so you're really earning less, but this is a useful baseline.

Now, before you buy something, do a quick mental math: "This costs $X. At my hourly rate, that's Y hours of my life. Is this purchase worth Y hours of my labor?"

You'd probably say yes to a $20 item if it genuinely solves a problem you have. You might say no to a $100 impulse purchase because 5 hours of labor for something you'll forget about in a week doesn't feel aligned with your values.

The power of this framework is that it makes value concrete. You're not saying "I shouldn't spend on this." You're making a real trade-off calculation: "Is this worth the amount of my life I'll have spent earning it?"

This also reveals something important about "convenience purchases." That $25 app that automates a task you spend two hours per week on? If it actually works, you've earned back those two hours per week forever. That's worth 25 hours of your time over just 12 weeks. That purchase is aligned with your value of protecting your time and energy.

Conversely, a $15 impulse purchase on a gadget that will sit unused is not aligned with most people's values. It costs three-quarters of an hour of your life and delivers nothing.

The ADHD-Specific Permission to Spend on Convenience

One of the most shame-inducing parts of having ADHD is watching other people manage tasks that feel impossible to you. They remember to pay bills on time. They cook dinner at home instead of ordering takeout. They make their own coffee instead of buying it daily. And the personal finance world constantly tells you that you're wasting money by choosing convenience.

Here's the difference: for you, convenience isn't just about preference. It's about executive function.

If you work with a body double (someone working alongside you, in person or virtually) to pay bills, that's not a character flaw. It's a system that works for your brain. If you spend $40 per week on takeout because cooking and managing grocery shopping consume executive function you need for work and relationships, that's a real trade-off, not a failure.

The value-based spending framework lets you evaluate these decisions rationally. You could spend three hours per week planning meals, shopping, and cooking (equivalent to 15 working hours per week). Or you could spend $40 on takeout three times per week ($120 per week) and use those hours for something that feels more important to you.

If you earn $25 per hour, you're choosing between spending $120 to save 15 hours, or spending 15 hours to save $120. For many ADHD adults, that's actually a great trade-off. Your executive function is a scarce resource. Spending money to protect it is often aligned with your values—especially if your values include maintaining your career, your relationships, or your mental health.

The key is being intentional about it. You're not spending on convenience out of shame or because you feel broken. You're making a conscious choice that convenience is worth the cost because the alternative is worse for you.

Identifying Your Personal Money Values

Before you can spend in alignment with your values, you need to know what your values actually are. This is harder than it sounds, especially if you've been deep in shame about money for a long time.

Start with this: What do you actually enjoy spending money on? Not what you think you should enjoy. What actually brings you pleasure or relief?

If the answer is "buying things," that's useful information. Some people's nervous system genuinely calms down when they shop. That's not a moral failing; that's a real sensory or emotional experience. The question then becomes: can you honor that value while also meeting your other financial goals? Maybe you allocate $50 per month to guilt-free shopping. You get your nervous system regulation. You're also not derailing your finances.

If you love experiences—concerts, travel, eating out—that's your value. Financial security might matter too, but it's secondary to experience and joy. That's important information. A budget that tries to make you save 30 percent and spend 5 percent on experiences is going to fail because it violates your core value.

If you value freedom and autonomy, you might be willing to work less and earn less in exchange for a job that doesn't drain you. That's a value trade-off, not a financial mistake.

The clearer you are about what you actually value—not what you think you should value, but what genuinely matters to you—the easier it is to make spending decisions that don't feel like deprivation or failure.

Making Impulse Spending Intentional, Not Shameful

The most powerful shift you can make is reframing impulse spending not as a character flaw, but as data about your values and your current state.

When you spend impulsively, ask: "What is this purchase giving me right now?" Sometimes the answer is "dopamine because I'm bored." Sometimes it's "a sense of control in a chaotic day." Sometimes it's "proof that I deserve good things." None of these answers make you bad. They make you human, and specifically, they reveal something about what you need in that moment.

Once you understand the impulse, you can ask: "Is this the best way to meet that need?" If you're buying things because you're bored and understimulated, that's useful. Maybe you need to build more structure into your days, or maybe you genuinely need a small discretionary budget for occasional purchases that bring novelty and dopamine. Both are valid.

If you're impulse buying because you feel like you don't deserve good things, that's revealing a deeper issue with self-worth, not a spending problem.

Value-based spending doesn't eliminate impulse buying. It contextualizes it. Some impulse purchases will still happen—and if they're small enough and rare enough, they're fine. They're part of being human. The goal isn't perfection. It's alignment.

Setting Values-Aligned Budgets That You'll Actually Follow

Once you know your values, you can create a budget that reflects them instead of fighting them.

Most budgets allocate money based on percentages: 30 percent housing, 20 percent food, 10 percent savings, etc. This might not reflect your values at all. If you value experiences and relationships above almost everything, a budget that allocates 5 percent to dining and entertainment while you're forced to live in a tiny apartment is going to feel miserable. You'll abandon it.

Instead, start with what matters to you. What expenses are non-negotiable because they align with your core values? For some people, it's a comfortable home. For others, it's the flexibility to take time off work. For others, it's the ability to eat at restaurants regularly or travel.

Build your budget around those core values first. Then find ways to minimize spending on things that don't matter to you as much.

If you don't care about having expensive clothes but you love books, allocate less to clothing and more to books. If you value autonomy and would rather work less than buy more stuff, make that trade-off consciously.

The more a budget reflects your actual values, the more you'll naturally follow it. You're not depriving yourself. You're directing resources toward what matters to you.

Conclusion: Permission to Spend Aligned With Who You Are

Value-based spending is fundamentally different from willpower-based budgeting. It doesn't ask you to fight your impulses. It asks you to understand them and align them with what matters to you.

You won't stop making impulse purchases. You'll become more intentional about them. You'll stop feeling ashamed about convenience spending because you'll understand it's a legitimate trade-off. You'll build a financial life that reflects your actual values instead of the values you think you should have.

That shift—from fighting yourself to understanding yourself—is when money stops feeling like a source of shame and starts feeling like a tool that works for you.

Learn more about implementing value-based spending in your specific situation and life. Read more in the book or Buy on Amazon.

ADHD and Money for Adults goes deeper with the full step-by-step framework.